This text will be discovered within the MyWallSt App, alongside an audio companion. Sign up today for a free account and get entry to dozens of expertly written articles and analyst opinion items each month.
We’re about 10 months on from my First Look into Oatly (NASDAQ: OTLY), the maker of the extremely well-liked dairy different. It’s truthful to say that 2021 was not a form yr for newly public corporations as traders deserted progress at any value and have become way more involved with dependable earnings. With Oatly now buying and selling about 80% beneath its IPO value, it’s price reviewing what occurred to this hotly-followed inventory.
From my First Look:
Valuation-wise, we’re past nose-bleed ranges right here. The corporate is at present buying and selling at a market capitalization of $12.8 billion — a 26x gross sales a number of. Valuing corporations on a gross sales a number of is often reserved for high-growth, high-margin, recurring income enterprise fashions, like SaaS. Whereas Oatly is definitely high-growth, it solely generates gross margins of 30% (which contracted 2% final yr) and it doesn’t have any recurring income. Even when it was a high-growth, high-margin, recurring income enterprise, 26x is quite a bit.
A part of the MyWallSt ethos is that we settle for that premium companies will sometimes commerce at premium costs. Nevertheless, no enterprise is price an infinite amount of cash and generally you might want to take a move, notably with an organization that was so new to the general public markets.
It was, in fact, straightforward to grasp the place all that hype was coming from. When Oatly went public final yr, stories emerged that it had attracted a star-studded lineup of traders that included Oprah Winfrey, Jay-Z, Beyonce, Natalie Portman, and even Starbucks’ Howard Schultz. The corporate had spent thousands and thousands of {dollars} plastering its billboards throughout the nation and oat milk was the fastest-growing dairy different in america. On high of that, Oatly had secured one of the crucial prized partnerships within the house with Starbucks, which launched numerous Oatly-based drinks nationwide.
Issues have been going so effectively that Oatly even invested in a Tremendous Bowl industrial, through which its precise CEO sits in a subject of oats singing a music he wrote himself with the lyrics “Wow, wow, no cow”.
No, I’m not joking, you possibly can watch it right here.
All of it appeared to be working effectively. Oatly, which was already the dominant oat milk model in Europe, was aggressively increasing into new markets like the UK, America, and even China. A novel advertising and marketing marketing campaign that leveraged baristas at among the coolest espresso spots acquired the phrase out that oat milk was a gorgeous dairy different and demand was spiking.
From my First Look:
Within the UK, dairy options noticed 31% progress in 2020, whereas Oatly grew 99%. In Germany, dairy options grew 44%, whereas Oatly grew 199%. And within the U.S., dairy options grew 20%, whereas Oatly grew 182%. It’s vital to notice that these are all recently-entered markets, so that they’re ranging from a low baseline, however nonetheless, the numbers are spectacular.
Nevertheless, profitable advertising and marketing is just one a part of working a profitable enterprise and the wheels shortly began coming off.
What occurred with Oatly’s enlargement into the U.S.?
Oatly’s U.S. enlargement can actually solely be described as a catastrophe. The corporate raced to satisfy the demand that its intelligent advertising and marketing had created, solely to place its complete enterprise in severe jeopardy.
The challenges with constructing new factories have been completely underestimated. Budgets swelled and timelines got here and went. In accordance with paperwork obtained by The Wall Avenue Journal, at one manufacturing facility in Millville, the corporate was creating 4 instances extra wastewater than they initially specified to metropolis officers.
From The Wall Avenue Journal:
Oatly started trucking the wastewater to Pennsylvania for disposal, the paperwork present. Executives mentioned the prices of including a wastewater remedy system, a fixture at many meals vegetation used to take away contaminants from water, and the price of the trucking disposal methodology, which totaled no less than $104,000 a month, the paperwork present.
At one other plant in Ogden, Utah, executives informed the board it could value $50 million to retrofit an previous Hershey’s plant for manufacturing. It ended up opening greater than a yr later than anticipated, costing greater than $100 million.
All this delay triggered chaos for Oatly’s distribution companions. Many smaller grocers have been left with empty cabinets and needed to supply oat milk from different suppliers. The espresso outlets that had been early adopters and spearheaded the model have been left having to purchase cartons at retail — if they might discover them. Even its trophy shopper, Starbucks, was left with out. Simply weeks after the launch of their co-branded drinks, the espresso chain needed to take away them from their app till they have been restocked. They subsequently signed up with an Oatly competitor to fulfill buyer demand.
Since then, Oatly has managed to get no less than a few of its factories’ issues so as and elevated its provide. Nevertheless, to do that, it has needed to depend on co-packaging and hybrid manufacturing fashions that squeeze profitability. In 2021, the corporate solely managed to self-manufacture 21% of all its merchandise, with 79% coming from both co-packaging or hybrid. That noticed gross margins within the final quarter drop from 27.7% to fifteen.9%. The corporate claims this was because of COVID-related provide chain disruptions and new facility start-up prices, but it surely’s clear from the beneath graphic that shifting manufacturing fashions are the place the fault lies, and proper now they’re removed from their long-term objectives.
Who’s Oatly’s Competitors?
All of the whereas, opponents haven’t been sitting on their arms. Oatly might have created this market, however it’s now removed from the one participant. SunOpta, which additionally makes soy and almond milk, was the enterprise that Starbucks partnered up with when Oatly let it down.
Chobani, a serious yogurt producer, managed to launch its first oat milk product in beneath 12 months, and received a serious deal to provide Tim Hortons in December final yr. Danone, which owns the Silk model of dairy options, and Califia Farms have additionally expanded into the house, whereas Planet Oat, made by dairy large HP Hood, has overtaken Oatly as the highest U.S. promoting model.
In the meantime, Oatly has come beneath hearth from teams and even an promoting watchdog in the UK over its environmental claims.
Is Oatly a great funding proper now?
It’s not all doom and gloom for Oatly. In its newest report posted simply final week, the corporate gave reasonably good steering for the approaching yr. Income is ready to return in at between $880 and $920 million — between 37% and 43% progress. The corporate additionally believes it’s going to hit a run price capability of 900 million liters by the top of the yr — virtually double what it may produce in 2021. Nevertheless, it didn’t specify how a lot of that’s going to be produced internally and capital expenditure is ready to leap considerably. That can imply both it points new shares — not nice once you’re down 80% — or it takes on debt, which received’t be low cost.
Even at these depressed ranges, I see lots of challenges for this enterprise. I believe Oatly might must even take into account a change in administration — which can significantly influence the corporate narrative.
Furthermore, I believe there’s a fantastic lesson right here to be discovered for traders. Generally companies come alongside and seize lots of consideration just because they’re the one pure-play in an thrilling house. Corporations could make us imagine they’re the way forward for a selected house with cool branding and a compelling narrative. Ultimately, with no sustainable aggressive benefit, it’s not possible to stop the larger gamers from making your life arduous.
In the meanwhile, I don’t see Oatly’s days getting a lot simpler any time quickly.
Don’t neglect that you would be able to hearken to this weblog without cost within the MyWallSt App. Sign up today for a free account and get entry to dozens of expertly written articles
