Plaintiffs’ attorneys and Florida’s insurance coverage shopper advocate are pushing again on insurers’ plans to require arbitration to settle extra claims disputes. Some attorneys warned that the plans may result in authorized challenges and doubtlessly extra claims litigation.
“That’s going to be an actual subject,” mentioned Dan Rheaume, a trial lawyer in Hollywood, Florida, who represents owners in claims disputes. “They’re taking away the insured’s day in court docket. There can be challenges to that.”
Rheaume was reacting to information that broke in early April that the Florida Workplace of Insurance coverage Regulation had permitted an endorsement submitting by American Integrity Insurance coverage Co. The insurer will supply premium reductions if owners conform to mediation or binding arbitration, for brand new insurance policies beginning April 22 and for renewals beginning June 21.
Different insurance coverage corporations’ leaders have mentioned their corporations are actually contemplating comparable endorsements as a manner to assist scale back the acute quantity of claims litigation that has plagued the trade in Florida for the previous few years. One provider’s executives met on the plan proper after phrase unfold about American Integrity’s approval.
However arbitration might not be in the perfect curiosity of policyholders, mentioned Tasha Carter, the insurance coverage shopper advocate on the Florida Division of Monetary Companies.
“I positively assume increasingly insurance coverage corporations shifting to incorporate a compulsory arbitration clause in owners insurance policies must be a priority for policyholders,” Carter mentioned. “Arbitration may put policyholders at an obstacle.”
Non-litigation options can remove a number of the authorized protections customers now get pleasure from, together with the best to trial by choose or jury, and, normally, appeals to a better court docket, she mentioned.
Carter mentioned her workplace plans to scrutinize comparable endorsement requests that different insurers could file with OIR in coming months, and will submit feedback.
Below American Integrity’s endorsement, if a home-owner initiates a dispute over the worth of a declare, it ought to first go to mediation then to confidential, binding arbitration.
Enthusiastic about Claims?
Get automated alerts for this matter.