This text is will be discovered within the MyWallSt App, alongside an audio companion. Sign up today for a free account and get entry to dozens of expertly written articles and analyst opinion items each month. If you happen to like this one, join extra.
That is half certainly one of a two-part collection. For the second and ultimate a part of the story, click here.
Let’s play a sport of ‘Solely Join’. What do the controversial navigation app RedZone, a nationwide community of psychics, and Chaka Khan all have in widespread? They’re all linked to financier Ted Farnsworth.
Farnsworth is America’s most unfazed businessman. He begins corporations like he’s amassing Starbucks rewards or airline miles. In response to the Miami Herald, he has registered 50 companies within the state of Florida within the final 30 years. Much more awe-inspiring, solely 4 of those have been nonetheless in operation by 2018 and the three that he took public noticed their worth drop by 99% inside three years of itemizing.
To not point out Farnsworth has been the goal of eight totally different civil fits revolving round unpaid payments and has been cited 11 instances for failing to pay federal earnings taxes on time.
Farnsworth’s ventures have included a pay-per-call psychic service touted by La Toya Jackson, two power drink corporations, a vitamin producer, and a few run-of-the-mill multi-level advertising and marketing schemes.
All of those titans folded in spectacular vogue.
First was the Psychic Discovery Community, the epitome of ‘90s hotlines and their infomercials. Its 900 quantity racked up cellphone payments throughout the nation earlier than the Federal Commerce Fee stepped in. The Community had greater than 50 shopper complaints on file, main the FTC to label its gross sales techniques as “abusive” in 1998. Farnsworth said he knew nothing of those complaints however he did promote his stake within the enterprise.
Subsequent up was the XStream Beverage Community, which stumbled onto the market in 2001 and drummed up investor pleasure in 2002 when it tried to accumulate European power drink, Darkish Canine. Founder and CEO Farnsworth dubiously labeled Darkish Canine because the Pepsi to Crimson Bull’s Coke, considerably embellishing its efficiency and recognition within the area. Sadly, the deal by no means materialized and Farnsworth resigned in 2007 as the corporate was relegated to the world of penny shares.
Not a month later and he was again on the scene with the Purple Beverage Co. The “antioxidant-rich drink” went public by way of a reverse merger with a movie firm. For just a few months it dazzled buyers with its spectacular array of movie star spokespeople earlier than collapsing within the wake of the Nice Recession. This was adopted by LTS Nutraceuticals, which vanished nearly as quick because it had appeared on account of a failure to “make required regulatory filings”.
Whereas he was down, Farnsworth was not out. In 2015, he based Zone Applied sciences, the creator of RedZone Maps, a navigation app that diverts you round “hazard and crime” utilizing crowdsourced data.
Critics have been fast to level out this sort of information assortment promotes racial profiling, however that didn’t cease Farnsworth. He hyped the corporate a lot it attracted the eye of Helios and Matheson Analytics, an equally murky and troublesome IT and information administration firm primarily based in New York. Helios and Matheson purchased RedZone in 2016, making Farnsworth Chairman. He would change into CEO three months later.
This is able to set Ted Farnsworth on a collision course with 2017’s most notorious firm: MoviePass.
Mission: Unattainable
MoviePass was based in 2011 by Stacy Spikes and Hamet Watt. Spikes was a music and movie government who had the thought for a film theatre subscription way back to 2005 however couldn’t discover any buyers or companions.
On the time, film theaters and manufacturing corporations have been targeted on upselling, therefore the dramatic rise in 3D cinema and big-budget photos. Theatres believed that in the event that they elevated spectacle, they may justifiably increase ticket costs and make up for any lower in theatergoers. When James Cameron’s ‘Titanic’ got here out in 1997, it was the highest-grossing and most costly film ever made.
However issues modified significantly between 2005 and 2011.
The film theatre enterprise appears to be one of many nice quandaries of the fashionable age. It someway manages to be in a perpetual state of decline and but thrives in periods of financial uncertainty. Throughout the Nice Melancholy — regardless of mass layoffs, widespread bankruptcies, and hundreds of thousands of foreclosures — Hollywood entered its Golden Age. All through the interval, between 60 and 80 million People went to the flicks as soon as every week or extra. Not lengthy after, the tv arrived. In 1946, British cinema attendance was a staggering 1.6 billion. By 1965, this quantity had fallen by greater than 75%.
The cinema enterprise ebbs and flows. When the 1981-82 recession hit, the worst for the reason that Nice Melancholy, American theatre attendance jumped by greater than 10%, whereas the unemployment fee rose sharply. In 2009, throughout the peak of the Nice Recession, ticket gross sales have been up greater than 17% whereas attendance rose by 16% year-over-year.

Nonetheless, by 2011, issues have been coming to a head. The increase of Recession escapism and the novelty of 3D have been rapidly waning. 2011 marked the worst yr for motion pictures in additional than 15 years. Ticket revenues dropped by 4.5% year-over-year whereas theatre attendance continued its regular decline. That very same yr, Netflix turned the biggest supply of Web streaming visitors in North America and it launched its first authentic collection: ‘Home of Playing cards’.
Possibly it was time to revisit the subscription service concept.
No Nation for Outdated Males
By 2011, Spikes and Watt got here collectively to lift $1 million in enterprise capital and launch a subscription trial in San Francisco. Preliminary demand shocked them. Regardless of solely being provided in 21 theatres, 19,000 customers tried to enroll on the primary day, crashing the corporate’s server. However, there have been nonetheless a number of kinks to work out.
First off, MoviePass didn’t inform any of the included cinemas that the service was launching, leaving many questioning why they have been out of the blue being inundated with digital bookings. Most of them stopped accepting MoviePass tickets inside three days.
On prime of this, MoviePass hadn’t fairly labored out how finest to collaborate with theatre chains so it was merely reserving tickets on behalf of its members by way of MovieTickets.com. Sadly, MovieTickets.com is owned by AMC and the theatre big wasn’t pleased its personal web site was being commandeered by a third-party service. It threatened authorized motion towards MoviePass, so it was again to the drafting board.
A second take a look at launched just a few months later in collaboration with Hollywood Film Cash, a nationwide reward card firm. With Cash’s 36,000 theaters, MoviePass launched in new markets, creating membership charges primarily based upon common native ticket costs. Subscriptions price between $29 and $34 a month, had a restricted variety of motion pictures, and required customers to print a voucher to redeem at their theatre. This was rapidly deemed too cumbersome and annoying and was changed by an app and digital vouchers. However, as soon as once more, AMC stepped in and pressured Hollywood Film Cash to interrupt off its partnership with MoviePass or threat dropping entry to hundreds of theaters.
Undeterred, Spikes and Watt raised extra capital and gained key buyers AOL and William Morris Endeavor. Collectively, they approached Uncover Card and struck a deal to launch the MoviePass debit card. This allowed for a seamless ticketing course of as MoviePass would load the price of tickets onto the cardboard and members would use it to pay on the field workplace. It additionally backed film theatre chains right into a nook as they have been compelled to just accept the playing cards anyplace they accepted a daily Uncover card. Worse nonetheless for AMC, MoviePass’ recognition finally attracted the eye of MasterCard.
By 2014, the MoviePass MasterCard had made its debut, which means greater than 91% of all cinemas in the USA could possibly be accessed by a subscriber. This, mixed with the continued decline in theater attendance, broke AMC and the chain agreed to enter into a short lived partnership with MoviePass.

Misplaced in Translation
In January of 2015, the one-year AMC-MoviePass pilot program was launched in Boston and Denver. On the time, MoviePass had just a few thousand subscribers paying round $32 a month. This fee was raised to between $35 and $45 upon request from AMC, with further prices for premium codecs like IMAX and 3D. In trade, subscribers may see one film a day. MoviePass agreed to pay face worth for tickets and AMC would pay to entry detailed shopper information.
This partnership was an enormous deal for MoviePass as a result of it was the primary time it had an opportunity to legitimize its enterprise mannequin within the eyes of the broader business. Spikes and Watt believed that this system was their alternative to show {that a} subscription service would improve cinema foot visitors and concession gross sales. The hope was this could finally incentivize film theatres to promote tickets to MoviePass at a reduction, which may outcome within the service turning into worthwhile.
Over the course of the yr, MoviePass and AMC ready information for a white paper report. The outcomes have been revealed in early 2016 and issues appeared fairly combined.
Preliminary figures confirmed the common AMC moviegoer heads to the cinema one and half instances a month. After MoviePass, it elevated to simply over 3 times monthly. Nonetheless, this influence was not long-lasting. The speed regressed again in the direction of the pre-MoviePass common because the service’s novelty wore off. If customers didn’t go to the flicks at the very least two instances a month, they have been paying extra for a MoviePass subscription than the corporate would spend on tickets, which means it may flip a wholesome revenue from customers’ forgetfulness.
In response to Enterprise Insider, officers inside AMC have been unimpressed and satisfied they may create a greater and extra profitable subscription service in-house. Some even believed that MoviePass had deliberately skewed information to its profit.
For that reason, AMC terminated its settlement with MoviePass and as soon as once more the 2 have been at odds.
If We Construct It, They Will Come
Regardless of disappointing the biggest film theatre chain on the earth, MoviePass wouldn’t hand over. In June 2016, Mitch Lowe, a former government of Netflix and RedBox turned MoviePass’ CEO. Stacy Spikes turned co-chairman with Hamet Watt.
Lowe was fast to flaunt the service’s supposed strengths: it was in style with Millennials, its subscribers spent 120% extra on concessions, and it elevated a movie’s theatrical launch window by incentivizing patrons to move to the flicks after opening weekend. In response to Lowe, if MoviePass may purchase “3 million subscribers, it could actually add 5 % to whole ticket gross sales”. This could have been nice information for theatre homeowners and manufacturing corporations, to not point out that MoviePass hoped to at some point promote studios detailed shopper information to assist them higher choose and launch movies.
However these silver linings weren’t sufficient to make up for the truth that MoviePass was missing its key ingredient: subscribers — heaps and plenty of subscribers.
After its AMC pilot, MoviePass’ limitless plan remained at an eye-watering $50 a month. In response to the corporate, this was to make sure MoviePass may “bear the danger of over-usage, and get the advantage of under-usage”. Clearly, this was not a deal customers have been keen to take, as MoviePass had a mere 20,000 subscribers and $10 million in income.
Then, Lowe struck up a friendship with Brian Schultz, the CEO of Studio Film Grill, a small chain of Texas-based cinemas identified for its in-theater eating expertise. In December of 2016, Studio Film Grill bought a stake in MoviePass. The identical week, Shultz introduced Studio Film Grill would supply its prospects a one-month, limitless MoviePass trial for $10. This occasion would change into a lovely case of foreshadowing.
Whereas Lowe admitted the momentary measure would “be costly”, he believed it was a crucial “a part of their subscriber acquisition prices”. Studio Film Grill was looking forward to the deal within the hopes it could improve their already spectacular concession income because of the reality they served full meals and alcoholic drinks. However with a mere 24 areas, it was unclear how a lot of an influence the deal would have for MoviePass.
The Massive Lebowski
A yr later, MoviePass was struggling. Subscriber numbers remained low, prices excessive, and there was no signal of any main theater chain coming again to the negotiating desk.
With their dream on the road, Spikes and Lowe took investor conferences in New York, and there they met Ted Farnsworth.
Upon first impression, one former MoviePass worker known as him a “bumbling, lovable, form of optimistic man” who “needs to be your finest pal”.
One other known as him a “con artist”…
The ridiculousness of MoviePass couldn’t be contained in a single piece, click here for Part 2.