The price of settling office class-action lawsuits reached a file excessive in 2021, defying expectations that the COVID-19 pandemic would lower the scale and cut back the variety of payouts, based on a new report by the Seyfarth Shaw regulation agency in Chicago.
“The plaintiffs’ bar capitalized on a recovering economic system and aligned priorities with the brand new Biden Administration to safe a file monetary haul in 2021,” said the creator, Seyfarth associate Gerald L. Maatman Jr. “Because the protection primarily based on arbitration agreements with class motion waivers faces elevated assaults throughout the nation, employers can take a look at this previous yr as a precursor to new authorized challenges and an explosion of sophistication and collective actions in 2022.”
Seyfarth’s 18th annual Office Class Motion Litigation Report says it examined a file variety of 1,607 class motion rulings in 2021. The evaluation contains all rulings within the federal and state court docket programs.
The regulation agency studies the combination quantity of the highest 10 non-public financial settlements in every of 5 classes of office class motion lawsuits; employment discrimination, wage and hour, Worker Retirement Revenue Safety Act, statutory non-public actions and governmental employment. Altogether, the whole of the highest ten settlements in every of the classes was $3.62 billion in 2021, surpassing the earlier excessive of $2.72 billion set in 2017 and dwarfing the $1.58 billion paid out in settlements in 2020.
Seyfath mentioned a legislative development to guard privateness and private information in workplaces will probably generate extra class motion litigation in 2022.
Employers noticed will increase in settlement values for wage and hour claims, ERISA filings and personal statutory claims, however decreases within the quantity spent to resolve employment discrimination lawsuits and authorities enforcement litigation.
The highest 10 non-public plaintiff statutory settlements—instances involving biometric privateness, breach of contract or violations of the Honest Credit score Reporting Act and Employee Adjustment and Retraining Notification Act, skyrocketed to a brand new excessive of $1.67 billion. The earlier file was $487 million in 2017.
These settlements embrace an settlement by the College of Southern California to pay $852 million to settle a category motion by 702 victims who declare they have been sexually abused by the college’s workers gynecologist. Sutter Well being in Northern California agreed to pay $575 million to settle litigation that accused the hospital system of abusing its market energy to lift costs and pressure well being plans to make use of its suppliers, the report says.
Seyfath mentioned a legislative development to guard privateness and private information in workplaces will probably generate extra class motion litigation in 2022.
Allegations that employers mishandled retirement plans additionally led to massive settlements final yr. The highest 10 ERIA settlements value a complete of $837 million, double the $380 million complete in 2020 and the $376 million complete in 2019.
“Repeated waves of 401(okay) price litigation have introduced extra than simply litigation complications for employers; the numerous publicity offered by these instances has induced many fiduciary legal responsibility insurers to make vital coverage modifications that make protection costlier and tougher to acquire,” the report says.
The highest ten settlements of wage and hour class instances value $641.3 million final yr, up from $294.6 million in 2020 and $449.05 million in 2019. Seyfarth mentioned the variety of filings elevated in 2021, maybe on account of a backlog that developed throughout COVID-19 pandemic lockdowns.
“We count on these numbers to rise ever additional in 2022 with a extra employee-friendly U.S. Division of Labor actively working to remove pro-business guidelines and shifting its regulatory focus towards a plaintiff-friendly agenda,” the report says.
Seyfarth mentioned the Biden Administration has reversed lots of the pro-business insurance policies adopted throughout Donald Trump’s presidency. For instance, the Division of Labor rescinded a regulation that took impact in March 2020 that created a four-factor balancing check to find out whether or not a employee is an worker or impartial contractor. Different modifications could come after the Equal Employment Alternative Fee loses its majority of Trump-appointed members later this yr.
Photograph: On this July 1, 2019, file photograph, Dr. George Tyndall, 72, listens throughout an arraignment at Los Angeles Superior court docket in Los Angeles. The College of Southern California agreed to pay $852 million to settle a lawsuit filed by 702 scholar who say they have been sexually abused by the workers gynecologist, based on the Seyfarth Shaw regulation agency.
Matters
Lawsuits
COVID-19
Trends
Commercial Lines
Business Insurance
Concerned with Enterprise Insurance coverage?
Get computerized alerts for this matter.
